Affiliate Disclosure: Some of the links on this page are affiliate links, which means we may receive a commission if you decide to buy a product or service we recommend.
Inheritance can be a touchy subject. One family has tried to mitigate that by implementing a long-standing tradition. However, when this man’s daughter announced that she wasn’t going to have kids, she was upset to learn that her inheritance wouldn’t change.
The original poster, Lucas, explains that in his family, inheritance involves children receiving small amounts of cash and sentimental items while grandchildren receive substantial trust funds.
This intentional, multi-generational distribution approach has worked successfully for many years.
This strategic rationale is in place to prevent any single generation from recklessly and irresponsibly spending all of the family’s collectively inherited wealth and assets.
As an example, Lucas’s brother quickly depleted his inheritance, but luckily, his children still received ample trust funds for their education and start in life.
Daughter Plans No Children
Recently, while Lucas finalized the details of his own will, his daughter approached him concerning her inheritance.
She informed him that she never plans to have children of her own, a decision that Lucas respects.
Lucas stated that under their current process, Emma would personally receive a collection of sentimental childhood souvenirs as well as a modest inheritance amount of approximately $5,000.
The daughter strongly objected that this dollar amount was substantially lower than what each of the older brother’s multiple children would ultimately receive.
Father Explains Rules
In response, Lucas patiently explained she had already received the bulk of her inheritance previously in the form of a trust fund from her late grandmother’s estate.
He reminded her of their longstanding rules dictating that only grandchildren inherit the lion’s share of assets, regardless of their parents’ portion.
Daughter Calls Unfair
Despite Lucas’s calm clarifications, his daughter argued that it was unfair for her to receive less money solely for choosing not to have children, which was not the case.
She called their family’s long-held inheritance tradition sexist and patriarchal.
Lucas Highlights Irony
In response, Lucas highlighted the irony that her daughter’s trust had come from the grandmother—noting that their family’s approach had been established initially and funded without any favoritism.
Lucas explains that this layered, multi-generational inheritance process has been carefully followed for many generations, and it has previously worked.
Request for Change Denied
The daughter insisted that Lucas should change the rules, believing it would make inheritance distribution in the family fair.
But Lucas refused to disrupt a process that had worked smoothly for generations just for his daughter’s desires, vowing to uphold consistency and tradition instead.
Daughter Is Greedy
“Sis actually wants to receive more money than all of her siblings, so she is doing some mental gymnastics to justify her greed,” one user said. “This system actually makes a lot of sense. It is fair and actually very generous since kids get access to family resources when they are still pretty young.”
Same Inheritance Amount Even with Kids
“Even if her hypothetical kids get an inheritance, it’s not her money, and she won’t be getting more or less out of it,” someone else said. “Same with your grandchildren. The money they receive doesn’t belong to your son.”
A Good Tradition
“Honestly, this is a great tradition,” a third user said. “People inherit money at a good point in life when they can really use it versus getting a lump sum in their golden years. She already received her money.”
In the end, the daughter maintains her view that the policy is fundamentally unfair, while Lucas values upholding consistency.
Their core disagreement persists.
Father Seeks Daughter’s Inheritance Share for Newborn, Tensions Erupt After Unpleasant Response
This is the story of a young woman who inherited her grandparents’ estate after their deaths. Her father demanded some of the money to support his pregnant wife after he blew through his own inheritance — and showed his true colors when she refused.
He Repeatedly Pressures Wife to Spend Her Inheritance, so She Takes a Stand at New Year’s Eve Dinner
Spouses should support each other in times of crisis. Instead, this woman’s husband has been taking advantage of her inheritance since her mother’s death. His whole family expected her to pay for things until she finally put her foot down.
He Purchases a New Home and Car With Inheritance, After Discovering News Ex-Wife Seeks Justice
A man received a good chunk of money after his grandmother passed away. While he and his ex-wife had been co-parenting successfully, when she heard about his newfound wealth, she started making demands.
His Late Mother Repeatedly Ignored His Funeral Advice, Now He Refuses to Pay
After his father’s death, this man advised his mother to think about her own funeral. She repeatedly refused. When she passed away with no arrangements in place, his siblings were upset to learn he didn’t want to contribute to the funeral costs.
Woman Fights to Protect Her Children’s Future as Boyfriend’s Parents Eye Her Inheritance
A woman plans to use her inheritance to set up a good future for herself and her children. However, her boyfriend wants to use the money to help out his parents, who have made poor financial decisions in the past.